Rework or Replace Monk


Although the central place for design discussion is ##crawl-dev on freenode, some may find it helpful to discuss requests and suggestions here first.

Blades Runner

Posts: 548

Joined: Monday, 23rd March 2015, 05:29

Post Thursday, 16th June 2016, 04:23

Rework or Replace Monk

The two defining features of the Monk background have nothing to do with each other... Unarmed, and Piety boost. Rename Monk to "Devout" or something, and give them a weapon choice (including unarmed) like every other melee background. That's all. :geek:

For this message the author yesno has received thanks: 6
crate, duvessa, nago, rchandra, Sandman25, ydeve
User avatar

Zot Zealot

Posts: 982

Joined: Monday, 29th September 2014, 09:04

Post Thursday, 16th June 2016, 06:25

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

Good suggestion, I agree that unarmed and piety boost don't have much connection. I think starting Monk with a weapon makes it very similar to Fi/Gl though, so I've opened a pull request to start with generic fighting skills only.

https://github.com/crawl/crawl/pull/298

For this message the author chequers has received thanks:
yesno

Tomb Titivator

Posts: 832

Joined: Wednesday, 17th April 2013, 13:28

Post Thursday, 16th June 2016, 07:52

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

Do Fi and Gl get UC as a starting option for non-Trolls/Ghouls? If UC isn't a distinguishing feature for Monks anymore then maybe they should.

Slime Squisher

Posts: 352

Joined: Monday, 14th December 2015, 00:43

Post Thursday, 16th June 2016, 07:57

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

@chequers
Starting with just a bit more Fighting doesn't seem to make up for having to rely on 0 UC at XL 1, especially for species unable to get anything out of the Armour skill; better piety doesn't matter as you won't find an altar until XL 3 or so. Every other start has something to rely on even when starting unarmed, be it spells, ranged weapons (AM) or wands (Ar). Also depriving a Monk of Unarmed Combat makes it questionable if it's even a monk anymore - perhaps a class name change would make more sense.

Other than that, it's a decent idea.

Ziggurat Zagger

Posts: 8786

Joined: Sunday, 5th May 2013, 08:25

Post Thursday, 16th June 2016, 08:33

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

I think the change was intended to keep Mo the weakest background, not buff it.
User avatar

Zot Zealot

Posts: 982

Joined: Monday, 29th September 2014, 09:04

Post Thursday, 16th June 2016, 09:19

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

Yes, well more specifically I wasn't interested in what happened to the power level, as long as it didn't become significantly worse, or better than almost all others.

Suggestions for improvement are welcome: think the core of Monk is bonus piety and beyond that the background should be quite flexible.

Ziggurat Zagger

Posts: 11111

Joined: Friday, 8th February 2013, 12:00

Post Thursday, 16th June 2016, 14:25

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

I think it should start with Dodging, not Armour. Even guys in heavy armour train some Dodging but it does not make much sense to train Armour if you are going to use robe or leather. For example, DEMo can easily join Vehumet or Sif Muna and switch to robe of archmagi.
User avatar

Vestibule Violator

Posts: 1591

Joined: Saturday, 3rd August 2013, 18:59

Post Thursday, 16th June 2016, 17:08

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

I think it would be funny if monks started with almost no skills but got *****. instead of **....
To all new players: Ignore all strategy guides posted on the wiki, ask questions in the Advice forum, players with lots of posts normally have the best advice.

crawl.akrasiac.org:8080 <- take this link to play online or spectate.

Tartarus Sorceror

Posts: 1694

Joined: Tuesday, 31st March 2015, 20:34

Post Thursday, 16th June 2016, 17:33

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

I think UC and dodging are pretty thematic for a monk, they're seemingly based off the mythical kung-fu monks. Piety goes with that, and seems to work out. I think they're one of the most thematically tight backgrounds in the game actually. Whether the theme itself is worth having is perhaps debatable...

For this message the author dowan has received thanks:
Speleothing

Sar

User avatar

Ziggurat Zagger

Posts: 6418

Joined: Friday, 6th July 2012, 12:48

Post Thursday, 16th June 2016, 17:43

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

UC Monks is how Monks work in DnD IIRC (well, they also can use some "exotic" weapons), so I'd expect most new players to understand the background as it used to be pretty well.

For this message the author Sar has received thanks: 2
dowan, Speleothing

Tartarus Sorceror

Posts: 1694

Joined: Tuesday, 31st March 2015, 20:34

Post Thursday, 16th June 2016, 18:00

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

How about monks start with 0 piety, and 0 in all skills. However, we'll all agree to insist they are the most powerful background, and act like it should be completely obvious why.

Obviously I'll edit this post so as not to spoil the ruse.

For this message the author dowan has received thanks:
4Hooves2Appendages
User avatar

Slime Squisher

Posts: 354

Joined: Thursday, 14th April 2011, 17:28

Post Thursday, 16th June 2016, 20:49

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

Give them the option to start with a lajatang imo. Still fits the exotic weapon theme and gives them another option.
Maybe also have them start with boots/gloves/both?
infinitevox on akrasiac & berotato
Busy dying horrible deaths from chugging too many pots of Mutation.
User avatar

Ziggurat Zagger

Posts: 4478

Joined: Wednesday, 23rd October 2013, 07:56

Post Thursday, 16th June 2016, 21:03

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

infinitevox wrote:Give them the option to start with a lajatang imo. Still fits the exotic weapon theme and gives them another option.
Maybe also have them start with boots/gloves/both?

That would be quite a buff indeed.
DCSS: 97:...MfCj}SpNeBaEEGrFE{HaAKTrCK}DsFESpHu{FoArNaBe}
FeEE{HOIEMiAE}GrGlHuWrGnWrNaAKBaFi{MiDeMfDe}{DrAKTrAMGhEnGnWz}
{PaBeDjFi}OgAKPaCAGnCjOgCKMfAEAtCKSpCjDEEE{HOSu
Bloat: 17: RaRoPrPh{GuStGnCa}{ArEtZoNb}KiPaAnDrBXDBQOApDaMeAGBiOCNKAsFnFlUs{RoBoNeWi

For this message the author Sprucery has received thanks: 2
Sar, ydeve

Ziggurat Zagger

Posts: 4055

Joined: Tuesday, 10th January 2012, 19:49

Post Thursday, 16th June 2016, 21:43

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

maybe they could start with a quarterstaff and worship zin

For this message the author crate has received thanks: 6
Arrhythmia, nago, prozacelf, Sar, Tressol, ydeve

Blades Runner

Posts: 548

Joined: Monday, 23rd March 2015, 05:29

Post Thursday, 16th June 2016, 21:56

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

Sar wrote:UC Monks is how Monks work in DnD IIRC (well, they also can use some "exotic" weapons), so I'd expect most new players to understand the background as it used to be pretty well.


i know, but that's why i suggested a possible name-change to "devout" ( or "faithful", "pilgrim", maybe "acolyte" or something). also i didn't think reproducing DnD culture was a goal for Crawl design anyway, and besides even if it were, i don't think crawl's monk implementation meets the expectations a DnD player probably has (in DnD you gain unique unarmed/unarmored combat powers and resistances over long term, in crawl you gain quicker access to arbitrary set of divine abilities in the short term)

as for skills i don't know they could maybe start with like 2 invo... but... there are a lot of gods without invo after all. their skills can also just stay the same except for option of weapon skill and they'd be fine, or at least better than currently.

Blades Runner

Posts: 548

Joined: Monday, 23rd March 2015, 05:29

Post Thursday, 16th June 2016, 22:15

Re: Rework or Replace Monk


For this message the author yesno has received thanks: 2
chequers, Shard1697
User avatar

Tomb Titivator

Posts: 911

Joined: Thursday, 17th December 2015, 02:36

Post Thursday, 16th June 2016, 22:46

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

I agree that it's better to avoid the association between monks and unarmed combat;
yesno wrote: "pilgrim"
would be best: you are conducting a sacred pilgrimage to the dungeon, in search of legendary altars, and the rest writes itself.

Blades Runner

Posts: 548

Joined: Monday, 23rd March 2015, 05:29

Post Thursday, 16th June 2016, 23:08

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

yeah, i like that one too.
User avatar

Slime Squisher

Posts: 354

Joined: Thursday, 14th April 2011, 17:28

Post Thursday, 16th June 2016, 23:31

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

Martial Artist imo
infinitevox on akrasiac & berotato
Busy dying horrible deaths from chugging too many pots of Mutation.
User avatar

Blades Runner

Posts: 568

Joined: Wednesday, 5th March 2014, 03:52

Post Friday, 17th June 2016, 02:27

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

As a fan of crappy starting backgrounds, I am displeased.

(Really!)

Dungeon Master

Posts: 1051

Joined: Thursday, 12th June 2014, 05:19

Post Friday, 17th June 2016, 03:09

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

play mumo, my friend

Spider Stomper

Posts: 247

Joined: Monday, 10th November 2014, 21:32

Post Friday, 17th June 2016, 05:52

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

dowan wrote:How about monks start with 0 piety, and 0 in all skills. However, we'll all agree to insist they are the most powerful background, and act like it should be completely obvious why.

Obviously I'll edit this post so as not to spoil the ruse.


Oh gitp forums, how I missed thee and thy partially charged wands

Abyss Ambulator

Posts: 1233

Joined: Wednesday, 23rd April 2014, 21:57

Post Friday, 17th June 2016, 12:10

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

Reptisaurus wrote:As a fan of crappy starting backgrounds, I am displeased.

(Really!)

You can always start-scum for some truly horrendous Wanderers. They exist.

Crypt Cleanser

Posts: 689

Joined: Saturday, 12th December 2015, 23:54

Post Friday, 17th June 2016, 12:49

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

Rest in pizza demigod monk. You were too pure for this cruel world.
User avatar

Vestibule Violator

Posts: 1509

Joined: Wednesday, 21st September 2011, 01:10

Location: St. John's, NL, Canada

Post Sunday, 19th June 2016, 03:16

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

I'm just glad that good older suggestions can be redone, and might get followed!
Won all race/bg, unwon (online): Nem* Hep Uka
Favourites: 15-rune Trog, OgNe/OgIE/OgSu (usually Ash), Ds, Ru, SpEn, Ce of Chei, Qaz

Blades Runner

Posts: 548

Joined: Monday, 23rd March 2015, 05:29

Post Tuesday, 21st June 2016, 21:51

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

so i feel a little shy making another suggestion here after such a nice change was already made, but how about quarterstaves among options for monk starter? just seems like they should have one...

For this message the author yesno has received thanks: 3
Arrhythmia, duvessa, reosarevok

Shoals Surfer

Posts: 257

Joined: Thursday, 6th November 2014, 02:32

Post Tuesday, 21st June 2016, 22:06

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

dowan wrote:How about monks start with 0 piety, and 0 in all skills. However, we'll all agree to insist they are the most powerful background, and act like it should be completely obvious why.

Obviously I'll edit this post so as not to spoil the ruse.


Ah.. the ol' Chei trick.

Tomb Titivator

Posts: 832

Joined: Wednesday, 17th April 2013, 13:28

Post Wednesday, 22nd June 2016, 09:04

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

yesno wrote:so i feel a little shy making another suggestion here after such a nice change was already made, but how about quarterstaves among options for monk starter? just seems like they should have one...


It's getting harder and harder to tell Mo and Gl apart... or is that the intention? Stealth removal by making 2 backgrounds the same :twisted:

For this message the author DracheReborn has received thanks: 2
nago, ydeve

Blades Runner

Posts: 548

Joined: Monday, 23rd March 2015, 05:29

Post Wednesday, 22nd June 2016, 14:35

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

mo doesn't have armor or nets and has lower fighting and weapon skills...

Shoals Surfer

Posts: 325

Joined: Tuesday, 13th October 2015, 06:02

Post Saturday, 25th June 2016, 08:03

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

The only buff Monk needs is for Fo to have upwards to 4 attacks with UC.

For this message the author TonberryJam has received thanks:
Shard1697
User avatar

Tartarus Sorceror

Posts: 1762

Joined: Monday, 14th October 2013, 01:05

Post Saturday, 25th June 2016, 09:05

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

TonberryJam wrote:The only buff Monk needs is for Fo to have upwards to 4 attacks with UC.
3 unarmed punches without shield(and 1 with) would not be broken. I'm in favor
Image

Swamp Slogger

Posts: 184

Joined: Tuesday, 4th November 2014, 07:22

Post Monday, 27th June 2016, 18:52

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

The point of the monk is that you're trading your starting gear for the piety. Since you have no starting gear, you have no weapon, thus unarmed skill. Piety is a somewhat limited resource, perhaps analogous to a Gladiator's nets (and weapon/armor/helm) or a Fighter's might potion (and weapon/armour/shield). Giving up the gear means giving up the skill associated with the gear. I don't understand what's wrong with this arrangement. Next people will be asking for Fi to start with Evo instead of Shield skill, because not all fighters want to wear shields the whole game.
"This spell will have no effect right now because your brain is too dead to use."

Ziggurat Zagger

Posts: 11111

Joined: Friday, 8th February 2013, 12:00

Post Monday, 27th June 2016, 19:03

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

That's actually a problem with artificers/hunters. Why do they start with short blades?

Sar

User avatar

Ziggurat Zagger

Posts: 6418

Joined: Friday, 6th July 2012, 12:48

Post Monday, 27th June 2016, 19:05

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

Because they need some weapon, but giving them a good one would be too good. I guess?

For this message the author Sar has received thanks:
Sandman25

Swamp Slogger

Posts: 184

Joined: Tuesday, 4th November 2014, 07:22

Post Monday, 27th June 2016, 19:47

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

Artificers and Hunters aside, the piety and the unarmed on monks are in fact related, as I explained above.

I would be happy for Artificer to start with a quarterstaff, but that could be OP I guess. Hunters could probably survive D1 even without a melee weapon. Perhaps short blades are for flavor in that case? Hunters get DEX and stealth, so maybe a dagger is more appropriate than a short sword (for flavor as well).
"This spell will have no effect right now because your brain is too dead to use."

Blades Runner

Posts: 548

Joined: Monday, 23rd March 2015, 05:29

Post Tuesday, 28th June 2016, 01:08

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

Tressol wrote:The point of the monk is that you're trading your starting gear for the piety. Since you have no starting gear, you have no weapon, thus unarmed skill. Piety is a somewhat limited resource, perhaps analogous to a Gladiator's nets (and weapon/armor/helm) or a Fighter's might potion (and weapon/armour/shield). Giving up the gear means giving up the skill associated with the gear. I don't understand what's wrong with this arrangement. Next people will be asking for Fi to start with Evo instead of Shield skill, because not all fighters want to wear shields the whole game.


monks don't get armour, aux armour, nets, a shield, or a might potion, or as much weapon skill ...
User avatar

Vestibule Violator

Posts: 1509

Joined: Wednesday, 21st September 2011, 01:10

Location: St. John's, NL, Canada

Post Tuesday, 28th June 2016, 02:10

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

Nor as good a weapon!
Won all race/bg, unwon (online): Nem* Hep Uka
Favourites: 15-rune Trog, OgNe/OgIE/OgSu (usually Ash), Ds, Ru, SpEn, Ce of Chei, Qaz

Swamp Slogger

Posts: 184

Joined: Tuesday, 4th November 2014, 07:22

Post Tuesday, 28th June 2016, 03:10

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

yesno wrote:
Tressol wrote:The point of the monk is that you're trading your starting gear for the piety. Since you have no starting gear, you have no weapon, thus unarmed skill. Piety is a somewhat limited resource, perhaps analogous to a Gladiator's nets (and weapon/armor/helm) or a Fighter's might potion (and weapon/armour/shield). Giving up the gear means giving up the skill associated with the gear. I don't understand what's wrong with this arrangement. Next people will be asking for Fi to start with Evo instead of Shield skill, because not all fighters want to wear shields the whole game.


monks don't get armour, aux armour, nets, a shield, or a might potion, or as much weapon skill ...


Interesting that you bring up weapon skill. According to the wiki (I'll check in game when I get home, I know the wiki blows), Monks get 4 UC and Gladiators get 3 skill in chosen weapon, Monks get 3 fighting to a Gladiator's 2. They get Stealth instead of Throwing at 2, and both backgrounds get dodging at 3. So, monks effectively get more overall starting exp, and posess probably better starting stats for a light armor type. But feel free to keep making up "facts" to support your position.

Edit: Facts checked. As of 0.18.1, these figures are still correct.
"This spell will have no effect right now because your brain is too dead to use."

Ziggurat Zagger

Posts: 8786

Joined: Sunday, 5th May 2013, 08:25

Post Tuesday, 28th June 2016, 03:24

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

Actually, both of you are pulling things out of your ass. Monks and gladiators currently get the exact same amount of weapon skill.

Swamp Slogger

Posts: 184

Joined: Tuesday, 4th November 2014, 07:22

Post Tuesday, 28th June 2016, 03:46

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

duvessa wrote:Actually, both of you are pulling things out of your ass. Monks and gladiators currently get the exact same amount of weapon skill.


I literally just checked *again* with a human monk and a human (unarmed skill) gladiator. You are wrong or trolling. I will post turn 0 morgue files if you need me to. Monks start with 4 UC skill, Gladiators 3. I ALSO made a weapon (maces & flails) gladiator just to check if that somehow made a difference. It did not. You are wrong. 0.18.1.

Kindly check your facts before you claim I'm pulling stuff out of my ass when I explained to you that I had just checked mine.
"This spell will have no effect right now because your brain is too dead to use."

Ziggurat Zagger

Posts: 4055

Joined: Tuesday, 10th January 2012, 19:49

Post Tuesday, 28th June 2016, 04:05

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

Uh, minmay was certainly talking about current trunk, where monks are not the same as 0.18 monks. If you read the commit that changed monks (linked earlier in this topic) you see that they do indeed have the same weapon skill gladiators do.

Ziggurat Zagger

Posts: 8786

Joined: Sunday, 5th May 2013, 08:25

Post Tuesday, 28th June 2016, 04:37

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

Tressol wrote:
duvessa wrote:Actually, both of you are pulling things out of your ass. Monks and gladiators currently get the exact same amount of weapon skill.


I literally just checked *again* with a human monk and a human (unarmed skill) gladiator. You are wrong or trolling. I will post turn 0 morgue files if you need me to. Monks start with 4 UC skill, Gladiators 3. I ALSO made a weapon (maces & flails) gladiator just to check if that somehow made a difference. It did not. You are wrong. 0.18.1.

Kindly check your facts before you claim I'm pulling stuff out of my ass when I explained to you that I had just checked mine.
Why are you talking about a two-month-old version of Crawl, when there is a link in this thread to a change made to Mo this month?

Swamp Slogger

Posts: 184

Joined: Tuesday, 4th November 2014, 07:22

Post Tuesday, 28th June 2016, 05:08

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

Well, I see that now. I don't generally follow Trunk, and I missed the link when first reading the thread so that's my mistake. Sorry for stirring things up, then.

In my defense, the version to which I was referring to was made clear in the edit on my ("talking out of my ass") post, and there were still no replies when I got home, checked .18.1 and then added said (version labeled) edit to the post.

I still don't think I like this change, but whatever - I hardly play Monks, anyway. If anything, these changes make them even less interesting to me.
"This spell will have no effect right now because your brain is too dead to use."

Blades Runner

Posts: 548

Joined: Monday, 23rd March 2015, 05:29

Post Tuesday, 28th June 2016, 23:20

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

duvessa wrote:Actually, both of you are pulling things out of your ass. Monks and gladiators currently get the exact same amount of weapon skill.


i thought gladiators got 4, my mistake, but there's no need to start talking like that just because that other guy is
User avatar

Slime Squisher

Posts: 354

Joined: Thursday, 14th April 2011, 17:28

Post Wednesday, 29th June 2016, 22:01

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

Don't mind duvessa, she's always inordinately angry to any given situation

Personally, I think monks should start with gloves or boots (or both)
infinitevox on akrasiac & berotato
Busy dying horrible deaths from chugging too many pots of Mutation.
User avatar

Tartarus Sorceror

Posts: 1762

Joined: Monday, 14th October 2013, 01:05

Post Wednesday, 29th June 2016, 23:40

Re: Rework or Replace Monk

Why? Gladiator getting aux armor is part of what sets it apart from monk(better gear overall). A big part of monk as a start is "minimal armor".

Return to Game Design Discussion

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 74 guests

Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group.
Designed by ST Software for PTF.