Page 1 of 1

Proposal: Crushing like a grape?

PostPosted: Tuesday, 16th July 2013, 19:12
by Siegurt
Minor text complaint:

"Crush" is to pulverize into powder, grind or pulverize between two objects as to cause breakage of brittle parts. Grapes aren't "breakable" or "pulverizable" being a squishy thing.

The thing you do to a grape is called squishing, when you use a simile, for instance "You crush the <death yak> like a grape!" it has to use a verb which is applicable to the object.

I suggest that that message should be "You squish the <death yak> like a grape!" or "You smash the <death yak> like a grape!" or "You crush the <death yak> like <some thing that's particularly crushable>!"

"Smash" being the verb which can only refer to the action (hitting something with force) is at least non-specific and generic enough to apply to things which are either crushable or squashable (Smash being my second choice after squish, mainly because grapes aren't really any more smashable than anything else).

Re: Proposal: Crushing like a grape?

PostPosted: Tuesday, 16th July 2013, 19:13
by Igxfl
"You crush the crocodile like a crouton!"

Re: Proposal: Crushing like a grape?

PostPosted: Tuesday, 16th July 2013, 19:15
by Siegurt
Igxfl wrote:"You crush the crocodile like a crouton!"


*rofl* this would make sense *and* makes me giggle.

Re: Proposal: Crushing like a grape?

PostPosted: Tuesday, 16th July 2013, 19:31
by Arrhythmia
Merriam-Webster defines crush as "to squeeze or force by pressure so as to alter or destroy structure", and Oxford describes it as "deform, pulverize, or force inwards by compressing forcefully". Crawl's use of crush is totally consistent with these definitions.

is this really an issue

Re: Proposal: Crushing like a grape?

PostPosted: Tuesday, 16th July 2013, 19:44
by Igxfl
"You criticize the crawler like a curmudgeon!"

Re: Proposal: Crushing like a grape?

PostPosted: Tuesday, 16th July 2013, 20:04
by Siegurt
Arrhythmia wrote:Merriam-Webster defines crush as "to squeeze or force by pressure so as to alter or destroy structure", and Oxford describes it as "deform, pulverize, or force inwards by compressing forcefully". Crawl's use of crush is totally consistent with these definitions.

is this really an issue


Issue? No "Minor thing that vaguely annoys me and is easy to change should some dev feel the urge and agree with me" yes.

While you can "Crush a grape" a grape isn't particularly any more "Crushable" than anything else, so when you say "I'll crush you like a grape" why is the grape important in that sentence? Why is it any more significant to "Crush something like a grape" then it would be to "Crush something like a sandwich" or "Crush something like a pirate hat"?

Whereas using the verb "squish" we *know* that grapes are particularly squishable, to the point where it's become an idiom to "squish something like a grape" In the same way you could "Peel something like a banana" because Bananas are particularly "peelable"

Not that it's a big deal, everyone knows what "Crush" means and it's not like it's not communicated that it means "You hit them hard with a crushing weapon" it just feels awkward and a little mixed-metaphor-ish.

If you want something particularly "crushworthy" you'd use "a tin can" or some such.

Re: Proposal: Crushing like a grape?

PostPosted: Tuesday, 16th July 2013, 20:20
by Volteccer_Jack
mixed-metaphor

So glad you said that because now all I have to do to make my point is quote Shakespeare:

"to take up arms against a sea of troubles"

Re: Proposal: Crushing like a grape?

PostPosted: Tuesday, 16th July 2013, 20:24
by TeshiAlair
I CRUSH YOU LIKE A FORMICID.

Re: Proposal: Crushing like a grape?

PostPosted: Tuesday, 16th July 2013, 20:25
by Siegurt
Volteccer_Jack wrote:
mixed-metaphor

So glad you said that because now all I have to do to make my point is quote Shakespeare:

"to take up arms against a sea of troubles"


Shakespeare was a hack :p

Re: Proposal: Crushing like a grape?

PostPosted: Tuesday, 16th July 2013, 20:30
by One-Eyed Jack

Re: Proposal: Crushing like a grape?

PostPosted: Tuesday, 16th July 2013, 21:16
by Igxfl
Volteccer_Jack wrote:
mixed-metaphor

So glad you said that because now all I have to do to make my point is quote Shakespeare:

"to take up arms against a sea of troubles"


Repel/Deflect Missiles is a better solution on most characters.

Re: Proposal: Crushing like a grape?

PostPosted: Wednesday, 17th July 2013, 01:04
by nicolae
Siegurt wrote:While you can "Crush a grape" a grape isn't particularly any more "Crushable" than anything else, so when you say "I'll crush you like a grape" why is the grape important in that sentence?


because when you crush a grape it goes splat and you get mushy remains everywhere, presumably resembling the effect of applying your mace vigorously to a centaur's dome

is this your first time working with Metaphor and Imagery

Re: Proposal: Crushing like a grape?

PostPosted: Wednesday, 17th July 2013, 04:03
by mumra
One-Eyed Jack already gave the link but needless to say: this is a reference that a lot of people will understand and it's good crawl humour. Let's leave it at that eh ;)

Re: Proposal: Crushing like a grape?

PostPosted: Wednesday, 17th July 2013, 19:28
by Grimm
Ooooh I could lock a thread.