books with 1 spell
Posted: Tuesday, 6th November 2018, 07:16
so I was going to make a goofy shop vault with a shop that sells randart books that only have 1 spell each, and immediately realized "it's gonna be a real pain in the ass to examine each of those books to find out which spell they have", and indeed, it's already a pain in the ass to examine the 10 randart books that show up in every regular book shop.
and that got me thinking, what if, in place of randart books, there were books with just one spell? so they're just called "handbook of apportation", "handbook of fire storm", etc., and they'd generate in place of randart books (you could generate them in larger numbers to compensate for them only having one spell, naturally).
This has several advantages:
- First, obviously, it solves the shop problem.
- Randart books always have to get identified even if you already have all the spells in them. A single-spell book can be marked as useless if you already have the spell, just like other non-randart books.
- It's trivially easy to control the rarity of different single-spell books. Controlling the rarity of spells in randart books is much harder, unless you totally restructure the way randart books are generated, which would presumably shake up balance just as much as this change would.
- No more Sif/Trog altar vault spoileriness!
I do not think it would be a significant nerf to flat-out 1:1 replace randart books with single-spell books. Randart books are already nigh-irrelevant - they are rarer than regular books, have fewer spells, seldom have good combinations of spells, and are overpriced in shops. Might as well turn them into something that doesn't hurt the interface.
(For Sif Muna, just reduce the gift timeout by like 50%).
and that got me thinking, what if, in place of randart books, there were books with just one spell? so they're just called "handbook of apportation", "handbook of fire storm", etc., and they'd generate in place of randart books (you could generate them in larger numbers to compensate for them only having one spell, naturally).
This has several advantages:
- First, obviously, it solves the shop problem.
- Randart books always have to get identified even if you already have all the spells in them. A single-spell book can be marked as useless if you already have the spell, just like other non-randart books.
- It's trivially easy to control the rarity of different single-spell books. Controlling the rarity of spells in randart books is much harder, unless you totally restructure the way randart books are generated, which would presumably shake up balance just as much as this change would.
- No more Sif/Trog altar vault spoileriness!
I do not think it would be a significant nerf to flat-out 1:1 replace randart books with single-spell books. Randart books are already nigh-irrelevant - they are rarer than regular books, have fewer spells, seldom have good combinations of spells, and are overpriced in shops. Might as well turn them into something that doesn't hurt the interface.
(For Sif Muna, just reduce the gift timeout by like 50%).