duvessa wrote:I don't think Xom is even actually better than atheist for most (all?) species anymore, swaps are so frequent and so bad.
Yeah, that could be true. My current Tengu has 40 AC at only level 18 (thanks Xom!) but still comes close to dying all the time. And Xom's gifts really don't feel that great if you're not prepared to wait a million turns. (Or maybe the other gift giving Gods just spoil me with their artifact weapons.)
Still, it seems like Xom helps overall more than hurts. (Which doesn't make him a "good" God or better than atheist. If he makes 20% of dangerous fights more dangerous that's not a risk worth taking.)
But he has flat-out saved my ass on several occasions, too. And my poor ogre died on Vaults:4 due to a small army of monsters turning up on an already cleared level, and me not reading fog when running away, rather than Xom...
Although looking back Xom did change a Very Ugly Thing into a Golden Dragon. That might have actually been what killed me. I take it back. Screw you, Xom!