|Anonymous | Login | Signup for a new account||2019-07-19 08:51 CEST|
|Main | My View | View Issues | Change Log | Wiki | Tavern | News|
|Viewing Issue Simple Details|
|ID||Category||Severity||Reproducibility||Date Submitted||Last Update|
|0008456||[DCSS] Patches||feature||N/A||2014-04-27 23:04||2014-05-26 05:39|
|Status||resolved||Product Branch||0.15 ancient branch|
|Summary||0008456: Add new unrand: the Black Staff|
In the long tradition of 'unrands that will get the user killed' (shield of the gong, maxwell's, etc), the Black Staff is a staff that gives a universal spell enhancer, plus 6 int & 6 mp. However, every spell cast while wielding the staff costs 2hp * spell mp cost, in addition to the normal spellcasting cost.
The staff itself is a +6 vampiric quarterstaff, which is a decent weapon, and has a pleasing thematic synergy with the casting cost.
Placeholder tiles are included.
|Tags||No tags attached.|
0001-Add-the-Hellbinder-s-staff.patch [^] (19,578 bytes) 2014-05-03 19:49 [Show Content]
0001-Add-the-Hellbinder-s-Quarterstaff.patch [^] (19,909 bytes) 2014-05-06 05:08 [Show Content]
Added a new patch that renames the artefact to the 'quarterstaff of the Hellbinder', in response to understandable confusion about the weapon type.
It might be good to add this to the Hellbinder wizlab at a low likelihood (similarly to how the robe of clouds can show up in the Cloud Mage wizlab), but I'm nowhere proficient enough in vaultese to make that change.
Couple minor things:
I would prefer the name "Staff of the Hellbinder" but I can see the point if it has quarterstaff melee attacks.
Why does _spellcasting_god_conduct() remove the !crawl_state.is_god_acting()?
A) The refactoring of that function should be a separate commit.
B) I imagine it would fail with the Xom card.
_spellcasting_god_conduct() removes !crawl_state.is_god_acting() because the function is only called in one place (_spellcasting_side_effects()), which performs the check. It might be reasonable to move the check to the start of the function itself; I don't feel strongly about it either way.
I refactored the function because I'd thought it would be a good place to put the mana barbs code (sadly, not so). It didn't seem worth either pushing for a separate patch or reverting the refactoring; if you want to pull it out, however, I have no objections.
edited on: 2014-05-02 06:03
No need to make a new patch - just a separate commit. This can be done with git reset --soft and git adding things back manually, or I guess the committer could do it.
Oh, and I deleted the old patch since it was apparently outdated.
"Mana barbs" isn't a very good death message. Could just be "unholy magic"/"lifeforce drained by unholy magic" for terse/long perhaps?
1 HP per MP seems fine to me, especially considering that those it'll in theory be useful for will likely be conjurers or summoners.
In the description, "taken from the mana used every time its wielder casts a spell" should probably be "taken in addition to". Also the description ends with an ellipsis!
New patches with requested changes: fixed the description/death message, reduced hp/mp cost further (to 1:1), and pulled the _god_conduct change into a separate patch.
Concerned that the hp cost won't really be noticeable for anyone but deep elves, but I guess we'll see. It's easy enough to change back (or to some other value), of course.
edited on: 2014-05-04 08:15
+ if (!crawl_state.is_god_acting())
+ if (crawl_state.is_god_acting())
I won't have time to test compile it this weekend, but since it's independent of the unrandart I'll push the refactoring patch by Tuesday or so.
Also deleted the old patch.
edited on: 2014-05-06 05:04
Deleted the refactoring patch, since it's in Trunk. I have a commit which puts the you.spellcasting_unholy() bit back in, but it's so trival I'll just paste the commit:
Author: reaver <redact email because spammers>
Date: Mon May 5 22:43:06 2014 -0400
Squahsable Hellbinder patch
This patch add you.spellcasting_unholy() to the spell casting god
diff --git a/crawl-ref/source/spl-cast.cc b/crawl-ref/source/spl-cast.cc
index 03812b0..48e8b2b 100644
@@ -844,7 +844,7 @@ static void _spellcasting_god_conduct(spell_type spell)
const int conduct_level = 10 + spell_difficulty(spell);
- if (is_unholy_spell(spell))
+ if (is_unholy_spell(spell) || you.spellcasting_unholy())
|Ha - I literally just finished making that same change myself!|
|Pushed in 6f959b73ab6b, thanks!|
|2014-04-27 23:04||PleasingFungus||New Issue|
|2014-04-27 23:04||PleasingFungus||File Added: 0001-Add-the-Black-Staff.patch|
|2014-05-02 02:55||PleasingFungus||File Added: 0001-Add-the-quarterstaff-of-the-Hellbinder.patch|
|2014-05-02 02:58||PleasingFungus||Note Added: 0026006|
|2014-05-02 05:18||Reaver||Note Added: 0026009|
|2014-05-02 05:26||PleasingFungus||Note Added: 0026010|
|2014-05-02 06:01||Reaver||Note Added: 0026011|
|2014-05-02 06:02||Reaver||File Deleted: 0001-Add-the-Black-Staff.patch|
|2014-05-02 06:03||Reaver||Note Edited: 0026011|
|2014-05-02 14:24||MarvinPA||Note Added: 0026015|
|2014-05-03 19:49||PleasingFungus||File Added: 0001-Add-the-Hellbinder-s-staff.patch|
|2014-05-03 19:50||PleasingFungus||File Added: 0001-Refactor-_spellcasting_side_effects.patch|
|2014-05-03 19:52||PleasingFungus||Note Added: 0026027|
|2014-05-04 04:05||MarvinPA||Issue Monitored: MarvinPA|
|2014-05-04 08:09||Reaver||Note Added: 0026036|
|2014-05-04 08:15||Reaver||File Deleted: 0001-Add-the-quarterstaff-of-the-Hellbinder.patch|
|2014-05-04 08:15||Reaver||Note Edited: 0026036|
|2014-05-06 05:02||Reaver||File Deleted: 0001-Refactor-_spellcasting_side_effects.patch|
|2014-05-06 05:03||Reaver||Note Added: 0026060|
|2014-05-06 05:04||Reaver||Note Edited: 0026060|
|2014-05-06 05:08||PleasingFungus||File Added: 0001-Add-the-Hellbinder-s-Quarterstaff.patch|
|2014-05-06 05:08||PleasingFungus||Note Added: 0026061|
|2014-05-26 05:39||PleasingFungus||Note Added: 0026265|
|2014-05-26 05:39||PleasingFungus||Status||new => resolved|
|2014-05-26 05:39||PleasingFungus||Fixed in Branch||=> 0.15 development branch|
|2014-05-26 05:39||PleasingFungus||Resolution||open => done|
|2014-05-26 05:39||PleasingFungus||Assigned To||=> PleasingFungus|
|2014-12-22 00:00||MarvinPA||Issue End Monitor: MarvinPA|
|Mantis 1.1.8[^] Copyright © 2000 - 2009 Mantis Group|