|Anonymous | Login | Signup for a new account||2019-04-20 05:06 CEST|
|Main | My View | View Issues | Change Log | Wiki | Tavern | News|
|Viewing Issue Simple Details|
|ID||Category||Severity||Reproducibility||Date Submitted||Last Update|
|0004869||[DCSS] Upload: Graphics||trivial||N/A||2011-11-07 22:36||2014-09-13 22:26|
|Status||closed||Product Branch||0.10 ancient branch|
|Summary||0004869: More monster tile candidates|
Some more replacements for uniques, and some Tengu tiles to go into unused for potential Tengu monsters in the future. I submitted separately from my last tile submissions in case these need any major changes/are denied.
Left to right, top to bottom: Josephine, Nikola, Kirke, Jessica, Psyche, Erica, Azrael, Efreet, Shadow Fiend; Aizul, Guardian Serpent, Kraken(head), Tengu Conjuror, Tengu Summoner, Tengu Fighter, Tengu Skald, Tengu Hunter, Tengu (altered original tile so it can be shown with equipment.
|Tags||No tags attached.|
monstertiles2.png [^] (22,490 bytes) 2011-11-07 22:36
josephine.png [^] (1,300 bytes) 2011-11-09 19:52
azarael.png [^] (979 bytes) 2011-11-09 20:01
nikola.png [^] (1,545 bytes) 2011-11-12 20:18
monsters3.png [^] (5,384 bytes) 2011-11-15 22:52
trapdoor.png [^] (1,573 bytes) 2012-04-17 20:21
Josephine, Nikola: big improvements. There's one problem, though: neither of them have a fixed weapon -- and in fact, Josephine starts with a dagger.
Kirke, Jessica, Erica: I prefer the old one a bit.
Psyche: old one if far better IMO.
Azarael: uhm, he's supposed to be an efreet, not a genie. He's 100% fiery.
Shadow fiend: seems to be hard to see, old one didn't have that problem.
Aizul, guardian serpent: way better than coloured snake.
Tengu band: hell yeah. There are no tengus out of a couple of vaults currently, but even the Shoals one could take two of the tiles, and we can add more even if just to use these :p
edited on: 2011-11-08 05:22
I guess the idea with Azarael was the notion of blue flames being hotter than red ones, and now I think he looks like a Disney character, which is gross. Consider that one un-submitted.
I assumed Nikola's weapon was fixed -- in wizmode, 10 times out of 10 he generated with a sabre of electrocution.
I'll have a Josephine without a fixed weapon up sometime later, and if anyone likes that Efreet tile I can make a new Azarael one.
(Edit: The Tengu tiles were based on evktalo's Floating Rocks suggestion on the wiki, but whether or not that ever gets implemented they're my favorite race and I thought I'd lobby for better representation through the magic of pixels)
|Nikola is always generated with a sabre, yeah, but like almost all monsters he's allowed to upgrade it if he finds something better. His only quirk is to demand the electrocution brand.|
edited on: 2011-11-16 02:25
More new tiles, left to right: Tentacled Monstrosity, Red Devil, Iron Devil, Blizzard Demon (edit: in case it isn't clear here on mantis, there's electricity crackling around the blizzard demon tile as per the monster description)
Unassigning due to lack of time on my part.
Regarding Kirke, I like the tile here more generally, but her hair-do (tied up) and the colour of her dress (white) are better in the current tile. It'd be cool to see these features in the new tile.
|Uploaded a tile for a trapdoor spider -- I added it to this old entry of mine because I really want to see that Nikola go in someday, but I think it would be more of a faux pas to post a new issue for him.|
edited on: 2012-04-18 10:06
Just posting a note requesting someone to look at the issue or bothering people on ##crawl-dev is 100% fine, no need to add a new tile to this old issue just to get it to the top of the list. That being said, since none of these tiles seem to have been added yet, adding another tile to the batch probably wont make this any harder to process.
Of the newer tiles the only one I don't like is the tentacled monstrosity. The current one looks much more monstrous to me. Yours looks kind of cute, like it just wants to play. The current tile isn't great either, though.
The trapdoor spider looks a little weird, but the trapdoor spiders in crawl are pretty weird, so I suppose it's okay. It might not look good ingame, though.
Regarding the older tiles I agree with kilobyte and evktalo. Except for Erica, she spawns with a flaming falchion, the staff in her current tile gives a wrong impression.
I really, really prefer tiles to be added as separate issues, that way it's easy to track what has been installed and what not.
So far installed: trapdoor spider, Nikola.
|Noted, I'll keep things to new issues in the future! Batching things seemed more convenient and directly telling people to put my tiles in the game feels presumptuous. Since this issue is a bit muddled -- un-implemented tiles, implemented tiles, and ones that need to be revised -- maybe it would be better off closed? I have some edits to make, and can simply re-submit my revisions as a new issue.|
I've committed the blizzard demon, red devil, iron devil, guardian serpent, Aizul, Josephine and the tengu. (The old tengu tile was perfectly capable of being shown with equipment, so this is mostly for consistency when we add tengu using the other tiles.)
This leaves Kirke, Jessica, Psyche, Erica, Azrael and the Efreet, the shadow fiend, and the tentacled monstrosity, I think.
About the tentacled monstrosity, I agree with Galefury, it looks kind of cute. I think it's the small eye ;)
If you want to submit revisions to these tiles, it might be better to do it here so it's easier to compare. Just make sure to post a comment so we get notified, and if you have completely new tiles, post them in a new issue :)
|The tentacled monstrosity in monsters3.png looks to me like some form of abyssal plant, maybe some kind of sentient seaweed; I'm wondering if it should go in unused? Otherwise, I think everything needed from this issue has been used and we should close it?|
|closing many ancient, resolved tile submissions|
|2011-11-07 22:36||roctavian||New Issue|
|2011-11-07 22:36||roctavian||File Added: monstertiles2.png|
|2011-11-07 23:22||KiloByte||Note Added: 0015755|
|2011-11-08 05:14||roctavian||Note Added: 0015760|
|2011-11-08 05:22||roctavian||Note Edited: 0015760|
|2011-11-09 19:52||roctavian||File Added: josephine.png|
|2011-11-09 20:01||roctavian||File Added: azarael.png|
|2011-11-09 21:50||evktalo||Status||new => assigned|
|2011-11-09 21:50||evktalo||Assigned To||=> evktalo|
|2011-11-10 02:56||KiloByte||Note Added: 0015786|
|2011-11-12 20:18||roctavian||File Added: nikola.png|
|2011-11-15 22:52||roctavian||File Added: monsters3.png|
|2011-11-15 22:53||roctavian||Note Added: 0015869|
|2011-11-16 02:25||roctavian||Note Edited: 0015869|
|2012-02-15 13:04||evktalo||Note Added: 0017032|
|2012-02-15 13:04||evktalo||Assigned To||evktalo =>|
|2012-02-15 13:04||evktalo||Status||assigned => acknowledged|
|2012-04-17 20:21||roctavian||File Added: trapdoor.png|
|2012-04-17 20:25||roctavian||Note Added: 0017773|
|2012-04-18 01:18||Galefury||Note Added: 0017776|
|2012-04-18 01:27||Galefury||Note Edited: 0017776|
|2012-04-18 01:27||KiloByte||Note Added: 0017777|
|2012-04-18 07:51||roctavian||Note Added: 0017780|
|2012-04-18 10:06||Galefury||Note Edited: 0017776|
|2012-05-26 13:39||edlothiol||Note Added: 0018142|
|2013-03-14 22:08||mumra||Issue Monitored: mumra|
|2013-03-27 06:28||mumra||Note Added: 0021859|
|2013-05-07 17:35||edlothiol||Issue Monitored: edlothiol|
|2013-05-19 23:55||ontoclasm||Status||acknowledged => resolved|
|2013-05-19 23:55||ontoclasm||Fixed in Branch||=> 0.13 development branch|
|2013-05-19 23:55||ontoclasm||Resolution||open => done|
|2013-05-19 23:55||ontoclasm||Assigned To||=> ontoclasm|
|2014-09-13 22:26||roctavian||Note Added: 0027247|
|2014-09-13 22:26||roctavian||Status||resolved => closed|
|Mantis 1.1.8[^] Copyright © 2000 - 2009 Mantis Group|